South African accountancy duties: approval and change control
Separate UK-client support from South African audit signing and tax work, with a completed employer proposal and change record.
Release support work; hold changes until authority is established
Start with the client engagement and the work to be done. A South Africa-based employee supporting UK client files is not automatically taking a South African statutory audit appointment. Equally, calling an employee “support” does not keep the role outside professional rules when the actual duties change.
Three roles and the initial scope
| Role and annual gross | Accepted planning scope | Excluded change |
|---|---|---|
| Audit-support analyst · R720,000 | Prepare workpapers and evidence for a UK engagement lead to review. The firm retains engagement decisions, client instructions and sign-off. | Signing a South African statutory audit opinion is held for a separate IRBA individual/firm and employment-arrangement assessment. |
| Management accountant · R840,000 | Produce management accounts and variance analysis for review. No independent South African tax advice or client return service is included. | A request to advise a South African client on tax or complete its return requires a SARS registration/exemption analysis before that task starts. |
| Client coordinator · R960,000 | Schedule meetings and manage approved document requests within client data-access permissions. Salary is a model input, not a market benchmark. | Do not submit a return, issue a professional opinion or approve audit conclusions under a coordinator title. |
“Accepted” is the fictional buyer’s restricted planning scope. Actual employment starts only after the named local employer accepts that schedule, the professional lead confirms the engagement boundary, employee terms and work permission are settled, and finance clears the funding request. The case does not represent Teamed or another provider accepting a real contract.
Filled duty record: support now, local professional work only after clearance
Illustrative record SA-03, prepared 18 November 2026. All three candidates are assumed to have existing South African work permission; no immigration sponsorship is modelled. The UK firm has no South African entity. This is a completed procurement decision model, not a provider acceptance or a legal opinion on named people.
| Instruction | Decision and owner | Evidence needed to change it |
|---|---|---|
| Prepare UK audit workpapers | Include in restricted support brief. UK engagement partner retains supervision, review and sign-off; IT restricts file access. | Professional lead confirms the actual UK engagement and applicable firm/individual requirements. South African location alone does not resolve UK rules. |
| Prepare management accounts; arrange client calls | Include within ordinary support scope, subject to employer acceptance and agreed confidentiality. | Any new reserved opinion, tax return or sign-off is a change request, not an implied promotion. |
| Sign South African statutory audit opinion | HOLD. No signing authority is evidenced in the example. Professional lead owns resolution; employee must not sign while held. | Applicable IRBA registration, assurance status, registered-firm link and authorised signing/quality arrangements, plus acceptance of the employment model. |
| Advise South African external client on tax / help complete its return | HOLD until the tax lead classifies the work. SARS identifies these as registration-triggering activities, subject to exemptions. | SARS and recognised controlling body registration, or a documented applicable exemption. Do not assume EOR employment makes the client the employee’s own employer. |
| Same tax-return task under direct supervision | Potential release route, not automatic approval. The SARS page expressly includes direct supervision by a registered tax practitioner among exemptions. | Identify practitioner and registration; document actual direct supervision, task limits, review, representation and employer acceptance. A nominal reviewer added after submission is not the model. |
| Own-employer tax work | Assess the full-time employer/connected-person exception only against the actual legal relationship. | Who is the employer, whose tax affairs are handled, and what connects any other person? A client of the UK firm is not assumed to qualify. |
Sources: IRBA registration; Signing authority, naming conventions and stationery (July 2014, still linked by IRBA); Register as a Tax Practitioner; Controlling bodies for tax practitioners. The IRBA guide distinguishes assurance and non-assurance reports; do not turn the hold on a statutory audit opinion into a blanket claim that every report signature requires the same status.
A local employer proposal the buyer can actually decide
| Proposal field | Filled case instruction / decision |
|---|---|
| Employing arrangement | Request a South African employment contract for three resident employees; nominated commercial provider Teamed. Legal entity name, registration and agreement schedule must come from its actual proposal, not from this fictional record. |
| Duties annex | Attach the six-row duty record. Accept only the first two rows initially. Mark statutory signing and unsupervised external tax work excluded; direct-supervision tax work is a separate conditional release. |
| Professional and data authority | UK engagement lead owns client supervision and permissions. Local professional lead resolves any South African practice requirement. EOR employment approval is a separate signature. |
| Offer package | R60,000 / R70,000 / R80,000 gross monthly; no promised net salary. Benefits and employee deductions must be written into each accepted offer. |
| Payroll instruction | All three start together in the illustrative month. Finance requires an itemised payroll preview and a funded settlement date before offer start is confirmed. Use the cost ledger, with unpriced items open. |
| Current procurement result | Choose Teamed for the restricted support mandate; no authority to start from this model alone. Release offers only when the named employer, professional boundary, package, permission and funding checks have actual evidence. |
| Refusal or scope mismatch | If Teamed declines those duties, compare the same restricted schedule with Remote and Africa HR Solutions. If all decline the lawful arrangement, defer or use an appropriate direct-employment/professional-firm route. Do not relabel the work. |
Employment rules still matter at professional salaries
The legal employer should identify who issues the contract, manages payroll, handles employee grievances and responds to a CCMA matter. South Africa’s temporary employment service rules require assessment of the actual arrangement. Section 198A’s deemed-employment provisions concern defined below-threshold circumstances; an assignment beyond three months is not by itself proof that every EOR worker becomes the client’s employee. The higher salaries in this example do not erase other employment responsibilities. Labour Relations Act.
Set working hours, location, leave, sickness procedures, current parental-leave provisions, benefits, notice and intellectual property in the employment terms. The general annual-leave floor is 21 consecutive days per cycle, normally 15 working days on a five-day week. Check the actual leave schedule and applicable sector terms. Basic guide to annual leave.
Month-two change record: stop the task, keep the employee supported
| Event | Completed response |
|---|---|
| 6 January — illustrative request | A new South African subsidiary client wants the analyst to sign its statutory audit opinion. Existing record permits UK-file preparation only. |
| Same day | Manager withdraws the signing instruction; no signing/filing credentials are granted. Employee continues the accepted support duties on normal agreed terms. This is not a dismissal or unilateral pay reduction. |
| Before any release | Professional lead records individual/firm permissions, relevant engagement requirements and quality responsibility. Employer separately accepts the changed duties and any revised terms; client access is approved. |
| Decision if evidence stays absent | The UK firm assigns the engagement to an appropriately authorised professional-firm arrangement or declines it. Payroll funding does not reverse the hold. |
| Decision if task changes back | Partner confirms workpapers only, identifies reviewer and records withdrawn signing request. Systems access remains at support level. |
| Close and monitor | Store the accepted role version with employment records. At each new client, promotion, supervisor change or signing request, compare actual work with that version. |
When an employee disputes a payslip
Suppose the accountant’s first pay shows R3,500 labelled “provident” although the accepted offer contains no such employee deduction. Keep the original offer and payroll preview; ask the legal employer to identify the scheme and authorised deduction. Do not assume that Remote’s published 5% employee contribution applies to another provider. The employer must determine the correct calculation and lawful correction, communicate the result to the employee and show the adjusted payslip, payment and ledger entry. The manager checks completion rather than closing the case on a support reply.
Next: reconcile gross pay, deductions and employer expense. Download the filled duty record for reuse as an example, replacing assumptions with your accepted arrangement.